Friday, 22 February 2008

If You Could Ask The PJ Anything What Would It Be?

Two things I would like to ask.

1) Why and who put Goncalo Amaral in charge of the Madeleine McCann case when he was already heavily embroiled in controversy over the case of missing Joana Cipriano's mother Leona? They must have known he was an arguido himself, yet they allowed this. He should have been suspended while he was answering these charges.

2) When did they actually stop looking for Madeleine and on whose orders did they stop looking for her?


Anonymous said...

I agree with that view entirely. Ridiculous to be on the case at all given the history....


Tinkerbell43 said...

Does Alsabelia make a good cuppa ?

On a serious note, I would ask what do you really know about Murat and Malinka and who is covering for who in all of this.

Mum21 said...

My question to them would be
What the hell have you been doing for the last 10 months?
In between the long boozy lunches of course.

Tinkerbell43 said...

Hi Mum, well done for catching up with China, have we managed to catch up with anyone else ?

I'm so interested to hear everyones true views without having to be so guarded.

Anonymous said...

I would ask what they meant by they found dna in apt 5a which should not have been where it was....


where in Murat's house did they find Madeleine's dna.....


Anonymous said...

I gave ELAINE, SEAWITCH AND OLD HIPPY this blog address this afternoon.

Has someone got Chinadoll? If so I would like info please....


Tinkerbell43 said...

Hi Jane, yes Mum has managed to catch up with China, hopefully she will be joining us soon.

SassyP said...

Tinks, I got a mail from JoJam wanting to join us!

I'd ask:

How much they actually know and how much is guess work.

Why they didn't take up the British offer of help when it would have been of more use!

Rosiepops said...

Oh Brill has China joined us too? You know SeaWitch has under the Blunder Cops blog?

ha ha I love that Does Alsabelia make a good cup of tea?

I would like to know the true extent to which the Pj questioned Murat and Malinka too. I think there is a massive cover up going on somewhere.

Mum yes exactly, what have they been doing for 10 months? They still haven't got around to sending these elusive rogatory letters.

Tinkerbell43 said...

What I found particularly strange was, following the recent alleged requestioning of 5 in PDL, why do you think it was Luis Antonio that made the headlines ?

maureen7 said...

Oh! Who are you?


SassyP said...

Another would be if they regretted anything they had done and if they had the chance to do everything again, what would they do differently!

Rosiepops said...

Hey Tinks why indeed? Luis Antonio I wonder what it was they were asking those people? Does anyone have the names of the others that were questioned?

Anonymous said...

Hooray Gonc's going to court.

Portuguese detective who led the hunt for Madeleine faces trial over his conduct in another missing child case
By LUCY BALLINGER - More by this author » Last updated at 23:31pm on 22nd February 2008

Christabel said...

Hooray Gonc's going to court.

Missed name off above.

Chinadoll said...

Ask a question?

I would DEMAND that they come clean and admit they have no case against the parents of Madeleine McCann and that they lift their arguido status forthwith.
I would then DEMAND that they reconsider an outside review of the case, in the hope that an independent review may uncover evidence they have missed by focusing on the parents and barking up the wrong tree.

Rosiepops said...


Good post. Eaxactly. Are the PJ answerable to the Portuguese public?

Where has Athena gone? didn't see her post much in the dying days of the DE forum.

calcite51 said...

Hi, everyone - I'm so glad to see you all - thanks to Rosie for FINALLY getting me here.

I'v been spending time at Alsabella's web page because only because I didn't know where anybody was.

I think she should call it Alsabella's fan club. I told her I was joining to give her a check on reality. She told me I had to be polite. Oddly enough, different rules for the anti-McCanns (what a surprise, eh?) It was okay for some of the anti-McCanns to be rude - I called one of them out - told them to go read the etiquette part of Alsabella's rules.

I'm glad I found you guys - group hug and all that.

I don't know what's going on with DE they have a story on Madeleine but it isn't on-line.

helenm said...

I would ask why are Portuguese residents so frightened of the PJ? Whilst I have been living in POrtugal I have become aware that it is a 'no go' area to actually question them at all. You do not cross them, that is why I can understand Alsabella and her Portuguese friends attitude towards the PJ. Maybe this attitude stems from their past when Portugal was ruled by a fascist government.

Anonymous said...

for such a small, elite force, your percentage resignations/ posts elsewhere/ pending trials,/ leave of absence has reached a EEC high.


calcite51 said...

The three (3) whys:

Why were you investigating a case when you are being investigated for misconduct in another missing child case. Decency says you should have been requested to being removed from the case?

Why did we see vehicles right after Madeleine's abduction (vans, trucks, cars) on CNN crossing into Spain without any checks? Your officers sat in the vehicle and stopped no vehicles. Police work at its' best or what?

Why is it taking so long for long to come to some sort of conclusion on this case?

lisaj said...

I would ask...what evidence do you think you have or would like to have had on the McCanns and if you have this imaginary evidence...don't you think it is time for you to officially charge? Or are you waiting for a rabbits foot and a four leaf clover to decide the date!

Rosiepops said...

Hi Lisa

nice to see you over again and I agree with you. These questions are proving to be really informative. I am going to take a summary of them at the end of the week and see if I can put them all together and then put it up here.

We are in the other story

McCanns Want Montpellier Sighting Video"

fairly quite at the moment, it usually picks up in the evenings, bit for a new blog hasn't been so bad, we have had a few teething problems and have managed to quell blog wars! Which none of us on here really wanted anyway.

Would be really great to see you in the main discussion sometime. Take care Lisa x

Minute For Madeleine McCann

Locate IP Address on Map